Resistor Tetahedron
About points...
We associate a certain number of points with each exercise.
When you click an exercise into a collection, this number will be taken as points for the exercise, kind of "by default".
But once the exercise is on the collection, you can edit the number of points for the exercise in the collection independently, without any effect on "points by default" as represented by the number here.
That being said... How many "default points" should you associate with an exercise upon creation?
As with difficulty, there is no straight forward and generally accepted way.
But as a guideline, we tend to give as many points by default as there are mathematical steps to do in the exercise.
Again, very vague... But the number should kind of represent the "work" required.
When you click an exercise into a collection, this number will be taken as points for the exercise, kind of "by default".
But once the exercise is on the collection, you can edit the number of points for the exercise in the collection independently, without any effect on "points by default" as represented by the number here.
That being said... How many "default points" should you associate with an exercise upon creation?
As with difficulty, there is no straight forward and generally accepted way.
But as a guideline, we tend to give as many points by default as there are mathematical steps to do in the exercise.
Again, very vague... But the number should kind of represent the "work" required.
About difficulty...
We associate a certain difficulty with each exercise.
When you click an exercise into a collection, this number will be taken as difficulty for the exercise, kind of "by default".
But once the exercise is on the collection, you can edit its difficulty in the collection independently, without any effect on the "difficulty by default" here.
Why we use chess pieces? Well... we like chess, we like playing around with \(\LaTeX\)-fonts, we wanted symbols that need less space than six stars in a table-column... But in your layouts, you are of course free to indicate the difficulty of the exercise the way you want.
That being said... How "difficult" is an exercise? It depends on many factors, like what was being taught etc.
In physics exercises, we try to follow this pattern:
Level 1 - One formula (one you would find in a reference book) is enough to solve the exercise. Example exercise
Level 2 - Two formulas are needed, it's possible to compute an "in-between" solution, i.e. no algebraic equation needed. Example exercise
Level 3 - "Chain-computations" like on level 2, but 3+ calculations. Still, no equations, i.e. you are not forced to solve it in an algebraic manner. Example exercise
Level 4 - Exercise needs to be solved by algebraic equations, not possible to calculate numerical "in-between" results. Example exercise
Level 5 -
Level 6 -
When you click an exercise into a collection, this number will be taken as difficulty for the exercise, kind of "by default".
But once the exercise is on the collection, you can edit its difficulty in the collection independently, without any effect on the "difficulty by default" here.
Why we use chess pieces? Well... we like chess, we like playing around with \(\LaTeX\)-fonts, we wanted symbols that need less space than six stars in a table-column... But in your layouts, you are of course free to indicate the difficulty of the exercise the way you want.
That being said... How "difficult" is an exercise? It depends on many factors, like what was being taught etc.
In physics exercises, we try to follow this pattern:
Level 1 - One formula (one you would find in a reference book) is enough to solve the exercise. Example exercise
Level 2 - Two formulas are needed, it's possible to compute an "in-between" solution, i.e. no algebraic equation needed. Example exercise
Level 3 - "Chain-computations" like on level 2, but 3+ calculations. Still, no equations, i.e. you are not forced to solve it in an algebraic manner. Example exercise
Level 4 - Exercise needs to be solved by algebraic equations, not possible to calculate numerical "in-between" results. Example exercise
Level 5 -
Level 6 -
Question
Solution
Short
Video
\(\LaTeX\)
No explanation / solution video to this exercise has yet been created.
Visit our YouTube-Channel to see solutions to other exercises.
Don't forget to subscribe to our channel, like the videos and leave comments!
Visit our YouTube-Channel to see solutions to other exercises.
Don't forget to subscribe to our channel, like the videos and leave comments!
Exercise:
A resistor circuit has the shape of a tetrahedron with a battery on edge a and resistors on the other edges b to f see figure. center includegraphics#image_path:resistor-tetrahedron-# center abcliste abc Choose directions for the currents I_a I_b dots I_f through the six edges of the tetrahedron and derive the s for the four nodes P Q R and S Kirchhoff's node rule. Express I_d I_e and I_f through I_a I_b and I_c. abc Derive the s for the four loops PQR PRS PSQ and QRS Kirchhoff's loop rule. abc For the case of five identical resistors R_b R_c s R_f R find formal expressions for the currents I_a to I_f. abc Determine the currents for a system with Delta V VO R_b R_d RbO and R_c R_e R_f RcO. abcliste
Solution:
abcliste abc The s for the nodes are I_e + I_f I_d quad textnode P labelnode:P I_d + I_e I_a quad textnode Q labelnode:Q I_a I_b + I_c quad textnode R labelnode:R I_b I_c + I_f quad textnode S labelnode:S After some manipulations of the s we find I_d fracI_a + I_b - I_c labeleq:Id I_e fracI_a - I_b + I_c labeleq:Ie I_f I_b - I_c labeleq:If This means that we can express the loop s in b by only three currents I_a I_b and I_c reducing the number of unknown quantities to three. abc With the current directions from a we find the following loop s: Delta V R_e I_e + R_d I_d quad textloop PQR labelloop:PQR -R_e I_e + R_b I_b + R_f I_f quad textloop PRS labelloop:PRS -R_f I_f + R_c I_c - R_d I_d quad textloop PSQ labelloop:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c quad textloop QRS labelloop:QRS By substituting the expressions for I_d I_e and I_f this can be simplified to Delta V R_d + R_e I_a + R_d - R_e I_b + R_e - R_d I_c labelsimp:PQR -R_e I_a + R_b + R_e + R_f I_b - R_e + R_f I_c labelsimp:PRS -R_d I_a - R_d + R_f I_b + R_c + R_d + R_f I_c labelsimp:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c labelsimp:QRS abc Substituting R for each of the resistances R_b to R_f yields Delta V R I_a labelsym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelsym:PRS -R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelsym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelsym:QRS Solving this system of linear s yields I_a fracDelta VR I_b I_c fracDelta V R and with s refeq:Id to refeq:If I_d I_e fracDelta V R I_f abc With R RO we can write the system of linear s as Delta V R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PRS - R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelasym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelasym:QRS By solving this system we find for the currents I_a frac I_ IaP I_b frac I_ IbP I_c frac I_ IcP I_d frac I_ IdP I_e frac I_ IeP I_f -frac I_ IfP with I_ Delta V/R IP. vspacemm The negative sign of I_f tells us that the ased direction is wrong. abcliste
A resistor circuit has the shape of a tetrahedron with a battery on edge a and resistors on the other edges b to f see figure. center includegraphics#image_path:resistor-tetrahedron-# center abcliste abc Choose directions for the currents I_a I_b dots I_f through the six edges of the tetrahedron and derive the s for the four nodes P Q R and S Kirchhoff's node rule. Express I_d I_e and I_f through I_a I_b and I_c. abc Derive the s for the four loops PQR PRS PSQ and QRS Kirchhoff's loop rule. abc For the case of five identical resistors R_b R_c s R_f R find formal expressions for the currents I_a to I_f. abc Determine the currents for a system with Delta V VO R_b R_d RbO and R_c R_e R_f RcO. abcliste
Solution:
abcliste abc The s for the nodes are I_e + I_f I_d quad textnode P labelnode:P I_d + I_e I_a quad textnode Q labelnode:Q I_a I_b + I_c quad textnode R labelnode:R I_b I_c + I_f quad textnode S labelnode:S After some manipulations of the s we find I_d fracI_a + I_b - I_c labeleq:Id I_e fracI_a - I_b + I_c labeleq:Ie I_f I_b - I_c labeleq:If This means that we can express the loop s in b by only three currents I_a I_b and I_c reducing the number of unknown quantities to three. abc With the current directions from a we find the following loop s: Delta V R_e I_e + R_d I_d quad textloop PQR labelloop:PQR -R_e I_e + R_b I_b + R_f I_f quad textloop PRS labelloop:PRS -R_f I_f + R_c I_c - R_d I_d quad textloop PSQ labelloop:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c quad textloop QRS labelloop:QRS By substituting the expressions for I_d I_e and I_f this can be simplified to Delta V R_d + R_e I_a + R_d - R_e I_b + R_e - R_d I_c labelsimp:PQR -R_e I_a + R_b + R_e + R_f I_b - R_e + R_f I_c labelsimp:PRS -R_d I_a - R_d + R_f I_b + R_c + R_d + R_f I_c labelsimp:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c labelsimp:QRS abc Substituting R for each of the resistances R_b to R_f yields Delta V R I_a labelsym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelsym:PRS -R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelsym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelsym:QRS Solving this system of linear s yields I_a fracDelta VR I_b I_c fracDelta V R and with s refeq:Id to refeq:If I_d I_e fracDelta V R I_f abc With R RO we can write the system of linear s as Delta V R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PRS - R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelasym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelasym:QRS By solving this system we find for the currents I_a frac I_ IaP I_b frac I_ IbP I_c frac I_ IcP I_d frac I_ IdP I_e frac I_ IeP I_f -frac I_ IfP with I_ Delta V/R IP. vspacemm The negative sign of I_f tells us that the ased direction is wrong. abcliste
Meta Information
Exercise:
A resistor circuit has the shape of a tetrahedron with a battery on edge a and resistors on the other edges b to f see figure. center includegraphics#image_path:resistor-tetrahedron-# center abcliste abc Choose directions for the currents I_a I_b dots I_f through the six edges of the tetrahedron and derive the s for the four nodes P Q R and S Kirchhoff's node rule. Express I_d I_e and I_f through I_a I_b and I_c. abc Derive the s for the four loops PQR PRS PSQ and QRS Kirchhoff's loop rule. abc For the case of five identical resistors R_b R_c s R_f R find formal expressions for the currents I_a to I_f. abc Determine the currents for a system with Delta V VO R_b R_d RbO and R_c R_e R_f RcO. abcliste
Solution:
abcliste abc The s for the nodes are I_e + I_f I_d quad textnode P labelnode:P I_d + I_e I_a quad textnode Q labelnode:Q I_a I_b + I_c quad textnode R labelnode:R I_b I_c + I_f quad textnode S labelnode:S After some manipulations of the s we find I_d fracI_a + I_b - I_c labeleq:Id I_e fracI_a - I_b + I_c labeleq:Ie I_f I_b - I_c labeleq:If This means that we can express the loop s in b by only three currents I_a I_b and I_c reducing the number of unknown quantities to three. abc With the current directions from a we find the following loop s: Delta V R_e I_e + R_d I_d quad textloop PQR labelloop:PQR -R_e I_e + R_b I_b + R_f I_f quad textloop PRS labelloop:PRS -R_f I_f + R_c I_c - R_d I_d quad textloop PSQ labelloop:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c quad textloop QRS labelloop:QRS By substituting the expressions for I_d I_e and I_f this can be simplified to Delta V R_d + R_e I_a + R_d - R_e I_b + R_e - R_d I_c labelsimp:PQR -R_e I_a + R_b + R_e + R_f I_b - R_e + R_f I_c labelsimp:PRS -R_d I_a - R_d + R_f I_b + R_c + R_d + R_f I_c labelsimp:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c labelsimp:QRS abc Substituting R for each of the resistances R_b to R_f yields Delta V R I_a labelsym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelsym:PRS -R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelsym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelsym:QRS Solving this system of linear s yields I_a fracDelta VR I_b I_c fracDelta V R and with s refeq:Id to refeq:If I_d I_e fracDelta V R I_f abc With R RO we can write the system of linear s as Delta V R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PRS - R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelasym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelasym:QRS By solving this system we find for the currents I_a frac I_ IaP I_b frac I_ IbP I_c frac I_ IcP I_d frac I_ IdP I_e frac I_ IeP I_f -frac I_ IfP with I_ Delta V/R IP. vspacemm The negative sign of I_f tells us that the ased direction is wrong. abcliste
A resistor circuit has the shape of a tetrahedron with a battery on edge a and resistors on the other edges b to f see figure. center includegraphics#image_path:resistor-tetrahedron-# center abcliste abc Choose directions for the currents I_a I_b dots I_f through the six edges of the tetrahedron and derive the s for the four nodes P Q R and S Kirchhoff's node rule. Express I_d I_e and I_f through I_a I_b and I_c. abc Derive the s for the four loops PQR PRS PSQ and QRS Kirchhoff's loop rule. abc For the case of five identical resistors R_b R_c s R_f R find formal expressions for the currents I_a to I_f. abc Determine the currents for a system with Delta V VO R_b R_d RbO and R_c R_e R_f RcO. abcliste
Solution:
abcliste abc The s for the nodes are I_e + I_f I_d quad textnode P labelnode:P I_d + I_e I_a quad textnode Q labelnode:Q I_a I_b + I_c quad textnode R labelnode:R I_b I_c + I_f quad textnode S labelnode:S After some manipulations of the s we find I_d fracI_a + I_b - I_c labeleq:Id I_e fracI_a - I_b + I_c labeleq:Ie I_f I_b - I_c labeleq:If This means that we can express the loop s in b by only three currents I_a I_b and I_c reducing the number of unknown quantities to three. abc With the current directions from a we find the following loop s: Delta V R_e I_e + R_d I_d quad textloop PQR labelloop:PQR -R_e I_e + R_b I_b + R_f I_f quad textloop PRS labelloop:PRS -R_f I_f + R_c I_c - R_d I_d quad textloop PSQ labelloop:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c quad textloop QRS labelloop:QRS By substituting the expressions for I_d I_e and I_f this can be simplified to Delta V R_d + R_e I_a + R_d - R_e I_b + R_e - R_d I_c labelsimp:PQR -R_e I_a + R_b + R_e + R_f I_b - R_e + R_f I_c labelsimp:PRS -R_d I_a - R_d + R_f I_b + R_c + R_d + R_f I_c labelsimp:PSQ Delta V R_b I_b + R_c I_c labelsimp:QRS abc Substituting R for each of the resistances R_b to R_f yields Delta V R I_a labelsym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelsym:PRS -R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelsym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelsym:QRS Solving this system of linear s yields I_a fracDelta VR I_b I_c fracDelta V R and with s refeq:Id to refeq:If I_d I_e fracDelta V R I_f abc With R RO we can write the system of linear s as Delta V R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PQR -R I_a + R I_b - R I_c labelasym:PRS - R I_a - R I_b + R I_c labelasym:PSQ Delta V R I_b + R I_c labelasym:QRS By solving this system we find for the currents I_a frac I_ IaP I_b frac I_ IbP I_c frac I_ IcP I_d frac I_ IdP I_e frac I_ IeP I_f -frac I_ IfP with I_ Delta V/R IP. vspacemm The negative sign of I_f tells us that the ased direction is wrong. abcliste
Contained in these collections:
-
Resistance 3a 25-26 by by
-
Resistor Circuits by by

